Henrietta United
Rev. David Inglis Matthew
25:31-46
Thanksgiving
God’s Economy: 5. “The Circle of Giving”
Scripture
“When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the
angels with him, then he will sit on the throne of his glory. 32All the nations
will be gathered before him, and he will separate people one from another as a
shepherd separates the sheep from the goats, 33and he will put the sheep at his
right hand and the goats at the left.
34Then the king will say to those at his right hand,
‘Come, you that are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you
from the foundation of the world; 35for I was hungry and you gave me food, I
was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you
welcomed me, 36I was naked and you gave me clothing, I was sick and you took
care of me, I was in prison and you visited me.’
37Then the righteous will answer him, ‘Lord, when was
it that we saw you hungry and gave you food, or thirsty and gave you something
to drink? 38And when was it that we saw you a stranger and welcomed you, or
naked and gave you clothing? 39And when was it that we saw you sick or in
prison and visited you?’ 40And the king will answer them, ‘Truly I tell you,
just as you did it to one of the least of these who are members of my family,
you did it to me.’
41Then he will say to those at his left hand, ‘You
that are accursed, depart from me into the eternal fire prepared for the devil
and his angels; 42for I was hungry and you gave me no food, I was thirsty and
you gave me nothing to drink, 43I was a stranger and you did not welcome me,
naked and you did not give me clothing, sick and in prison and you did not
visit me.’
44Then they also will answer, ‘Lord, when was it that
we saw you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or naked or sick or in prison, and
did not take care of you?’ 45Then he will answer them, ‘Truly I tell you, just
as you did not do it to one of the least of these, you did not do it to me.’
46And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into
eternal life.”
Sermon
The hungry, the strangers, the ill-clothed, the
sick. Who do you think of when you hear
these words? I think of people like the
homeless, like refugees from the war in
Carolyn and I happen to share a Pilgrim ancestor in
common, so it’s doubtful that either of us and millions of other Americans
would be here, and that we’d have
Thanksgiving, if a native named Squanto hadn’t seen the Pilgrims’ plight and
had pity on them. Squanto stayed with
the Pilgrims from March until the November of the following year. He taught them where to catch the local fish
and eel. He helped them build warmer
houses and taught them how to grow food in that climate. He acted as their interpreter with the local
native Americans, and helped facilitate trading and a peace treaty. The Pilgrims’ governor William Bradford wrote
that Squanto was a "special instrument sent by God for their good beyond
their expectations."
“I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and
you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, I was
naked and you gave me clothing, I was sick and you took care of me, I was in
prison and you visited me.” Thank you,
Squanto, for devoting more than a year and a half of your life to saving my
ancestor, even though you had previously been kidnaped and enslaved by
Europeans.
The truth is, each of us is vulnerable in this
life. Even the biggest givers have to be
receivers sometimes. This was nowhere
more evident than in Sally Erwin’s hospital room the last two weeks. Sally had been one of the most active, giving
people I’ve ever known. At the end of
her life, she literally couldn’t lift a finger.
She couldn’t do anything but lie there and just be. And yet she was so gracious and grateful in
her receiving the love and care of her family, friends and medical staff,
everyone felt blessed by her in their giving.
Jesus said, “It’s more blessed to give than receive.” But my friend Jerry Rardin says, “It’s more
blessed to give, and receive, and give, and receive.” Sometimes it’s hard to tell the difference. It’s all part of the same circle.
The native Americans integrated that wisdom into their
culture. Imagine that you are a Puritan
and you come to a Native American lodge.
Your hosts want to make you feel welcome, so they ask you to share a
pipe of tobacco with them. They believe
that tobacco smoke is a form of prayer, and sharing the pipe is a sacred sign
of community and peace. As you leave,
the natives give you the pipe as a gift that honors you and your friendship.
You’re really pleased. You take the pipe home and proudly display it
in your house.
Time passes, and eventually members of the tribe come
to visit your house. They notice
their pipe prominently displayed. They
seem upset. You tell how much you
appreciate the pipe and how proud you are to have it, but that only seems to
make things worse. A native interpreter
tells you that the least you could do is offer them a smoke and send the pipe
back home with them. So you take the
pipe down from its place of honor and give it back. The natives leave, muttering how selfish and
rude these Europeans are. And you’re
about to give birth to the term “Indian giver.”1
What happened?
The natives didn’t want the gift back for themselves. For them, gifts are only gifts if they
continue to be given. Otherwise, they
stop being gifts and start being possessions.
They expected you to pass their gift on to someone else. If you were too selfish to do that, they
would have to do it themselves.
In his book The Gift, Lewis Hyde describes an
interesting custom among the Massim people who occupy a circle of
For me, this Kulu Exchange is a good picture of God’s
economy--what I think God intends our lives to be like. God gets the circle of giving going by giving
us a planet rich in resources, one that loves to bring forth a wild profusion
of life. God gifts us with life,
time, energy, and abilities. God gifts us with the capacity for language and
love, cooperation and community. And God
gifts us with minds to imagine, invent, organize, plan for the future, and
learn from our mistakes. We can create
communities where each person’s particular gifts are honored and developed,
where each person’s well being is important, and where knowledge, know-how and
wisdom are shared. As we pass on our gifts around and around to each other, how
rich and abundant everyone’s life could be. Life could be like a civilized
version of the Garden of Eden.
But there’s a serpent whispering in our ear, “You
could get more for yourself, you know.
Not only can you eat an apple from this tree, but if you grab them before
anyone else gets them, you can have them all for yourself. You can claim ownership of this tree, and
lease future picking rights to others, and then buy up all the apple trees and
lease their picking rights. You can then
make a leveraged buyout of all the other kinds of fruit trees. Then you can charge entrance fees to the
garden and throw trespassers into outer darkness. You can spay the trees with
chemicals and pesticides so that all the fruit looks like it’s made in
factories. You can get a patent on all
the seeds so you can make a profit any time new ones get planted. You can create a monopoly on the fruit
distribution business. You can register
‘Apple’ and ‘Blackberry’ as trademarks
and get royalties or win settlements any time anyone sells something using
those names. You can create fruity TV
characters, dolls, action figures, and T-shirts. Then you’ll have enough money
to pay off the government to ignore the trees and resources that are being
destroyed, the toxins that are being created, and the women and children who
are being exploited by the production of these products.”
I’m not against free enterprise or people finding
innovative ways to make a buck. But if
we see our lives as an answer to the question, “How much can I acquire for
myself?” rather than “How can we best keep the circle of receiving and giving
going?” our Garden of Eden will look more and more like a wasteland, our
economy will collapse on its own greed, and people will become alienated,
suspicious, competitive, and violent. We
need to decide together whether to keep the circle of receiving and giving
going or to break it up into a scramble of every person for themselves. Our
choice will determine whether we live in a lonely, hostile kingdom of greed or
a mutually beneficial and satisfying
Susanna Polomares tells how she became part of that
circle of receiving and giving when she was seven years old. Susanna’s mother was an Italian war
bride. Her parents had had a painful
divorce, and Susanna and her mother returned to
One cold fall day, her grandfather, Nonno Beppe,
announced he was going to walk all the way down the mountain to the town, where
there was electricity and shops. Susanna
was made to understand that he was making this long trip just to bring back a
special gift for her. Finally, she had
something to look forward to.
Her Nonno carried fresh vegetables down the long,
narrow path, and when he finally reached the town, he traded them for, not one,
but two gifts for Susanna. He put one in
each of his wool coat’s pockets to keep them safe. Finally, he arrived back home, tired but
triumphant, and burst through the door.
Susanna jumped up and down while her Nonno proudly
reached into his pockets and pulled out...two small, gooey sticks. He and Susanna looked at each other with
surprised puzzlement. Susanna’s uncles
burst out laughing. They were more
familiar with the modern delicacy of ice cream.
Nonno Beppe had never experienced it for himself, but he was certain
that it would make his forlorn granddaughter feel more at home.
By now, everybody was laughing hysterically–including
Grandfather and Susanna. In the midst of
all that hilarity, Susanna’s loneliness was transformed into the awareness of
how much these people loved her and wanted to do all they could to make her
happy.
Susanna writes,
The real gift I got from Nonno Beppe that day was the
knowledge that what we do for others is not as important as caring enough to
try. The ice cream might have been eaten
and forgotten, but because it melted in the loving warmth of my grandfather’s
coat, I’ve had Nonno Beppe’s greater gift every day of my life.3
Once Susanna recognized and received the true gift of
love, then she could in turn be its giver.
This story reminds us that love is really the common currency
of all the gifts that are passed around the great circle of giving. God created the universe in a great process
of creative divine love, and called it all good. And God created us in God’s
own loving image. We were created by
love for love. And God proclaimed all that He had made good. And God so loved the world that He gave His
only Son, that we might not perish having only survived, but might know eternal
life. All of life is a gift of love from
God.
And in today’s
teaching from scripture, Jesus urges us to keep that love circle going by
giving food to the hungry, drink to the thirsty, a warm welcome to the
stranger, clothing to the naked, our presence to those in prison, or ice cream
to the homesick. In other words, find
those who are feeling left out of this circle of giving in whatever way
that might happen, and include them in.
Jesus came as one of those forgotten, left out
people–a child born in a stable to a pair of peasants traveling a long way to
register for Caesar’s tax. And Jesus
always worked to make sure the lowest, the last and least were included in
God’s circle. So when we do that for the
left out in our midst and in our world, we do it for him. And when we fail to do that, when we think
that what we keep for ourselves matters more than their need, we break that
circle of giving that God put us in from our birth. When we break that circle, we separate our
self from the flow of God’s gracious love.
The definition of sin is “separation from God.” And that’s what hell is–separation from the
love, peace and hope that come from being a part of God.
The way to stay a part of God’s circle of life is
through thanks and giving. Like the participants in the Kulu
Exchange, we receive God’s gifts with gratitude, and we recognize that gifts
are only gifts if we pass them along and keep the circle going. Whatever we have to give can do
this–armshells, gooey wooden sticks, shawls we knit and crochet for women in
troubled parts of the world, a hammer we swing for the Habitat house, food we
bring for the food cupboard, money we
give for Haitians devastated by hurricanes or for all the meaningful ministries
this church undertakes, or the acts of ministry we undertake on the job, at
home or in our community. Any of these can be coinage in the currency of
love. And when they are given to those
who feel left out so that they are brought back into the great circle of
giving, Christ especially smiles on our gift.
So let’s enter that circle of giving right now. In this time of silence, become aware of the
gifts in your life that you are most grateful for. . . . And so that your gratitude can keep the
circle of thanks and giving going, what is one gift that you especially want to
share, so that the blessings of your life in turn becomes a blessing to others?
1. Adapted from a sermon by Rev. David Miles, “How to be an Indian Giver,” in
http://www.luthersem.edu/stewardship/resource_detail.asp?resource_id=1177
3. Susanna Palmares, “Nonno Beppe’s Gift,” in Chicken Soup for the Soul–Stories for a Better World, edited by Jack Canfield et al, Scholastic, Inc., 2005, pp. 65-68.